Pre-contractual Liability Right Recognised

pre-contractual-liability

Basing itself on a German judgement, the Maltese Court of Appeal recently delivered a landmark judgement on pre-contractual liability which is sure to shape local commerce. The case filed in the names Av. Peter Fenech noe vs. Department of Contracts concerned a claim for damages made by a consortium after its offer in response to a tender issued by the Department of Contracts for the provision and installation of a Traffic Management Information System was unjustly turned down. Despite the fact that the First Hall, Civil Court had established that the consortium had  been unreasonably disqualified on 27th June 2008,  the consortium could not materially be reconsidered in the selection process as the tender had been given to another entity in the interim.

Although the judgment handed by the Court of First Instance had cited previous decisions delivered by the Maltese courts dealing with pre-contractual liability, namely Giuffrida vs. Borg Olivier, Pullen pro et noe vs. Matysik et, Cassar vs. Campbell Preston, Grixti vs. Grech, Busuttil vs. Muscat noe, Portelli noe vs. Falzon et and Seguna et vs. Kunsill Lokali Żebbug as a basis for its decision, the facts of the case in question did were deemed not give rise to pre-contractual liability.

Findings by the Court of Appeal with regards to Pre-contractual Liability

However, when the case was taken to the Court of Appeal, the Court cited a 1911 German court decision referred to as Linoleumfall which established that when a legal relationship is born between parties in preparation for a purchase, it is very similar in properties to a contract producing legal obligations, thereby recognising the contractual basis of pre-contractual liability. Thus, it was decided that the Director of Contracts should in fact be held responsible for damages on the basis of the legal notion of pre-contractual liability. The court further stated that once a consensual legal relationship was created between the parties, the Department of Contracts could not ignore the consortium’s offer unless there was a valid legal reason. Thus, if one does not fulfil the conditions of his tacit obligation, it is equivalent to a party not observing contractual obligation. This was decided on the on 29th April 2016.

The Court ordered the Department of Contracts to provide compensation based on the damages which the company had ​incurred as losses in the submission of the tender bid, rather than loss of profits or lucrum cessans. This judgment is expected to be the cornerstone for further recognition by Maltese courts of the contractual basis of the notion of pre-contractual liability.

Property Sales to Foreigners in Malta

property-sales

The Law on Property Sales and Foreigners

According to provisions made in Chapter 246 of the Laws of Malta with regards to property sales, citizens of all European Union member states who have resided in Malta on a continuous, uninterrupted basis of a minimum period of five years BEFORE the date of acquisition of immovable property may freely acquire such property without the necessity of obtaining an acquisition permit (AIP). However, individuals who are not citizens of a European member state may not acquire any immovable property unless they are granted an acquisition permit issued by the Maltese tax authorities. With regards to those who need an AIP, the minimum price is also set in stone with foreigners being legally obliged to spend at least €104,500 for the purchase of a flat or maisonette and at least €174,000 for the purchase of any other immovable property.

Areas of Interest for Foreigners

While some may view these price ranges as being somewhat restrictive, Finance Minister Edward Scicluna recently said in parliament that almost 1,000 properties worth €400 million have been sold to foreigners over the last four years and that almost half of that number were in areas such as St Julian’s, Sliema, Swieqi, Gżira, Msida, Pietà, Ta’ Xbiex, Pembroke, San Ġwann, Qormi, Birkirkara, Ħamrun and Santa Venera, showing an overall preference by foreigners for the Northern Harbour district. Given that these areas are notoriously pricier than the south, it comes as no surprise that the value of the 482 properties mentioned by Mr Scicluna amounted to the princely sum of €175 million with an average of €363,881 being spent on each. The lowest number of property sales was registered in Żejtun, Birżebbuġa, Gudja, Għaxaq, Kirkop, Marsascala, Marsaxlokk, Mqabba, Qrendi, Safi and Żurrieq where a mere 38 properties were purchased and the total sum spent in this area was valued at €5.5 million. Moreover, in an interesting twist, a total of 115 properties collectively worth €25 million were bought by foreigners in the sister island of Gozo and despite the fact that properties in Gozo are markedly cheaper than in Malta, the average price of each property purchased was €220,801.

Why is this happening?

Given past trends, this boom in market dynamics and property sales is being ascribed to the revamped residency and visa programme launched last August which allows third country nationals to gain residence permits against an investment in interest-free government bonds of €250,000. Due to the fact that individuals given a residence visa can travel in the Schengen area as well as reside in Malta itself, it is of little wonder that investments in our little island have sky rocketed and property sales have increased.